Guest Post from Professor Tillman: Professor Shugerman (et al) vs. Professor Prakash (et al)

Seth Barrett Tillman says Jed Shugerman and Prakash have positions on this issue.

Tillman: "I do not think [the question] answerable as an originalist matter" Tillman suggests that we stick with the traditional norm for "accountability" when Academic-B can write a response.

Seth Prakash : Professor Shugerman wrote a Slate article on the Foreign Emoluments Clause in 2017 .

He says he has not published copies of the documents he claimed existed in his article.

He has not publicly sent me copies of those documents, he says, nor has he privately sent them to him.

He writes that if Shugman revises his position in light of my critique, that leaves him with a good seven years to decide what is fair.